Enhancing Biogas Recovery from Anaerobic Co-digestion of Human Excreta and Food Waste using Response Surface Method and Biochar Additives
No Thumbnail Available
Date
2023-09
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
KNUST
Abstract
Ghana shares similar challenges with other developing nations regarding waste management and access to clean energy. Fortunately,these two challenges are connected. A better waste management strategy would involve converting the organic waste fractions into biogas. Nevertheless, a thorough study of the physico-chemical characteristics of the feed stocks used in the anaerobic digestion process is essential to maximize the energy potential. Consequently, the first phase of this study examined the physical
chemical properties of some selected feedstocks, namely, human excrement (HE), food leftovers (FLO), kitchen residues (KR), and cowdung (CD) of Ghanaian origin using APHA standards and equipment. Results of volatile-to-total solid ratios (VS/TS), 0.97±0.001, 0.89±0.001, and 0.85±0.001 for HE, FLO,KR and CD, respectively, showed that all feed stocks had high biodegradable content.
though thecarbon-to-nitrogen(C/N)ratiosforFLO(22.14±0.26),KR(23.34±0.25)
and CD(26.19±0.47)werewithintheoptimalrange,thatofHE(8.29±0.09)was
significantly low.Withameanalkalinityof1219.67±1.53,630.00±0.58,590.00±
2.08 and15,730.00±6.00mgCaCO3 eq./L forHE,FLO,KRandCDrespectively,
it wasobservedthatonlyCDhastheoptimalalkalinityvalueforanaerobicdiges-
tion. Thisbroughtintoperspectivetheneedforco-digestion.Thesecondphaseof
the study,therefore,soughttoprovethehypothesisthatanaerobicco-digestionofHE,
FLO andKRcouldgeneratemorebiogaswhileremainingstableifpositivesynergis-
tic effectsareachieved.Arandomizedternarymixturedesignandaresponsesurface
approach wereusedtoascertaintherelationshipbetweensubstratemixture,biogas
yield, methaneyield,andsynergy.ThefindingsrevealedthatR9(78.8%HE:11.8%
FLO:9.4 %KR)hadthehighestmethaneyieldof764.79mLCH4/gVS andasyner-
gistic indexof3.26.Additionally,the3Dresponsesurfaceplotsshowedimportant
and sharedinteractionsbetweenHE,FLO,andKRwherebythepredictedresponses
increased withincreasingHEandKRfractionsanddecreasedwithincreasingFLO
fractions inthesubstratemixtures.Inthethirdphaseofthestudy,theexperimental
cumulativemethaneyieldfromtheoptimumanaerobicco-digestionratio,R9,wasfit-
ted tofivekineticmodelsandtheconemodelhadthebestfitrecordingan R2 value
of 0.9909.Finally,theeffectsofcoconutshell(CCN)andpalmkernelshell(PKN)
biochar dosages(3g,6gand10g)ontheanaerobicco-digestionofHE,FLOand
KR wereinvestigatedusingbatchmesophilicexperiments.Theresultsshoweddif-
ferences inthepeakoccurrencetimesandmethaneyieldswiththebiochar-amended
treatments peakingearlierthanthecontroltreatment.Further,methaneyield(456.25
mLCH4/gVS) increasedwhen3gofCCNbiocharwasused,depictinga23.31%in-
crease comparedtothecontrol(SM=370.03mLCH4/gVS). However,toohighCCN
biochar dosagesof6gand10grestrictedmethaneproductionduetoapotentialstress
on theanaerobicdigestionprocessbroughtonbytheaccumulationof H2 competitors
of methanogensthatmighthaveclonedontoexcessbiocharandweakeneditsDIET
benefit formethanogenesis.Furthermore,themethaneyieldwas368.69mLCH4/gVS,
similar tothatofthecontrol(SM)when3gofPKNshellbiocharwasaddedtothe
mixture offeedstocks.Nonetheless,methaneyieldincreasedby10.83%whenthe
dosage ofPKNshellbiocharusedwasincreasedto6g.Conversely,PKN10gobserved
a decreaseincumulativemethaneyield.Theobservedresultsindicatethatmicrobial
activityandkineticscouldpossiblyberestrictedbyexcessivedosageofbiochar.This
could beattributedtothepossibleadsorptionofvolatilefattyacids(VFAs)sincethe
adsorption mechanismofbiocharisnotselective.Hence,higheramountsofadded
biochar maynotnecessarilycorrespondtohigherdigestionefficiency.